Futures Prop Firms With No Consistency Rule: The Plan-by-Plan List

Every firm on this list computes the same ratio: your single best day divided by total profit over the window the firm defines (the whole evaluation, or the profit accumulated since your last payout). If the ratio is above the firm's percentage, you are not blocked from trading; you are blocked from passing or from requesting a payout until more profit on other days brings the best day's share down.

Worked example: a $2,000 best day. Under 50% you need $4,000 total profit. Under 40% you need $5,000. Under 35% you need $5,715. Under 30% you need $6,667. Under 20% you need $10,000. The percentage moves the required total by a factor of 2.5 between the loosest and tightest plans above.

A rule during the evaluation costs you time once. A rule at payout costs you time on every withdrawal, because the window resets after each approved payout at firms like Apex and Lucid. That is why the right-hand column matters more to a funded trader than the left.

Only one firm on this list, Take Profit Trader, has a funded program with no rule and an evaluation whose rule cannot fail you. Every other “no rule” plan either applies a rule to pass or carries a different cost. The exact list as of October 2026:

• Tradeify Select funded (Flex or Daily payout policy): 40% applies during the evaluation only. Trade-offs: 3 minimum trading days, Select 50K $165 one-time, no daily loss limit during the evaluation but a $1,000 (50K) DLL on the Daily payout policy, 5 funded accounts total at Tradeify. Tradovate offered.
• LucidFlex funded: 50% applies to pass. Trade-offs: 5 funded per household, DLL optional, payout caps $1,000 / $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,000 by size, up to 5 payouts then LucidLive. One-time fee from about $70 (25K). Tradovate offered.
• MyFundedFutures Rapid funded: 50% to pass (30% on Rapid EOD). Trade-offs: 2 minimum days, Rapid 50K $209 list (often 50% off), no DLL, intraday drawdown on Rapid, 5 sim-funded if 25K/50K only, 3 if any 100K/150K, T1 news prohibited on sim-funded. 90/10. Tradovate offered.
• MyFundedFutures Pro funded: 50% to pass. Trade-offs: 80/20 split, min payout $1,000, same account caps and news restriction as Rapid. Tradovate offered.
• Take Profit Trader PRO and PRO+: 50% soft rule during the Test does not fail you. Trade-offs: Test is a monthly subscription (50K about $170/month list, frequent promos), 3 minimum trading days since Aug 17, 2026, PRO one-time $130 (often waived), 80% split on PRO (90% on PRO+), PRO uses intraday trailing drawdown, 5 active PRO accounts, flat 1 minute around listed news. Tradovate offered.
• GOAT Flex funded: 50% to pass. Trade-offs: 80/20 split (90/10 as a paid add-on), payout windows 5th–8th and 20th–23rd, 5 funded per plan, no orders 2 minutes around high-impact news once funded. Flex 50K $109. Tradovate offered.
• GOAT Daily Payouts funded: 40% to pass. Trade-offs: DLL $500 / $1,000 / $1,500 / $2,250 by size, 90/10, payouts every 24 hours, copying permitted only within Daily Payouts accounts. Daily Payouts 50K $119. Tradovate offered.

Apex's EOD and Intraday evaluations have no consistency rule and no minimum trading days, which is where the “Apex has no consistency rule” claim comes from. On the Performance Account, Apex's help center is explicit: no single trading day may account for more than 50% of your total accumulated profit at the time of a payout request, on accounts bought on or after March 1, 2026. Legacy accounts keep the 30% windfall rule. The calculation resets after each approved payout.

In exchange Apex offers the largest cap on this list (20 PAs per household), a 100% payout split on new PAs, and up to weekly payouts after 5 qualifying days with a $500 minimum.

Lucid: LucidFlex is 50% to pass and none when funded; LucidPro is none to pass and 40% per payout cycle when funded; LucidDirect is 20%. Household cap 10 evaluations and 5 funded; 90/10; min payout $500.

Tradeify: Growth is none to pass and 35% when funded; Select is 40% to pass and none when funded; Lightning Funded is 20% / 25% / 30% on payouts 1 / 2 / 3+. 5 funded accounts total; 90/10.

MyFundedFutures: Rapid is 50% to pass (Rapid EOD 30%) and none when funded, 90/10, daily payouts, min $500. Pro is 50% to pass and none when funded, 80/20, min payout $1,000. Builder is none to pass and 50% at payout, 80/20.

Topstep applies its rule during the Trading Combine (best day under roughly half the profit target; topstep.com shows 55%, the help center 50%). On the Express Funded Account the Standard payout path has no rule and the Consistency path caps the largest day at 40% in return for higher payout caps. Topstep trades only on TopstepX for new accounts.

Funded Futures Family: Prime none to pass, 40% per payout cycle; Premier+ Standard 50% to pass (FastPass none), 40% funded for accounts on or after Sep 9, 2026; Velocity 40% / 40%; S2F 25%. GOAT: EOD Challenge 50% / 30%; 1-Day-Pass none / 35%; Flex 50% / none; Daily Payouts 40% / none; Instant Classic 20%.

Consistency is checked per account. If one leader's trades are mirrored to five follower accounts at the same multiplier, every account books the same daily P&L distribution and either all pass the check or none do. Copying does not dilute a big day; it repeats it. A trader on a 40% plan who books a $2,000 day has five accounts each needing $5,000 of total profit, not one.

TradeDupe mirrors a leader's fills, bracket TP/SL and modifications across accounts at any firm on this list that offers Tradovate (Apex, Lucid, Tradeify, MFFU, TPT, GOAT; Funded Futures Family with a written-confirmation caveat). It does not reach Topstep accounts. It has no feature that monitors or enforces consistency; the per-account math above is yours to track.

Help-center and policy pages used for the figures on this page:

• Apex: apextraderfunding.com/help-center/additional-helpful-items/50-consistency-requirement/ ; .../eod-trailing-drawdown-accounts/eod-evaluations/ ; .../legacy-helpful-items/what-are-the-consistency-rules-for-legacy-pa-and-funded-accounts/
• Lucid: support.lucidtrading.com/en/articles/12945790-lucidflex-evaluation-account ; 12945796-lucidflex-payouts ; 12890029-lucidpro-evaluation-account ; 12890109-lucidpro-consistency-percentage ; 12890164-luciddirect-payout-objectives
• Tradeify: help.tradeify.co/en/articles/10495915-growth-evaluation-accounts ; 12853921-select-evaluation-accounts ; 11083796-advanced-and-growth-funded-account-payout-policies ; 12853966-select-flex-and-select-daily-payout-policies
• MyFundedFutures: help.myfundedfutures.com/en/articles/11994562-consistency-rule-at-my-fundedfutures ; 11802636-traders-evaluation-simplified ; 13745661-payout-policy-overview-best-and-fastest-prop-firm-payouts
• Take Profit Trader: try.takeprofittrader.com/TPT-FAQs-nf40-4-0725 ; takeprofittrader.com/blog/3-day-evals
• Topstep: help.topstep.com/en/articles/8284197-trading-combine-parameters ; 8284215-express-funded-account-parameters ; topstep.com/topstep-prop
• Funded Futures Family: fundedfuturesfamily.com/payout-rules/ ; fundedfuturesfamily.com/prime-plan/
• GOAT Funded Futures: help.goatfundedfutures.com/en/articles/14095672-how-does-the-consistency-rule-affect-payouts ; 14523731-what-are-the-specifications-of-each-type-and-account-size